New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, Star Wars Theory: [SPOILER] Was Behind the Death of Anakin's Mother. But whether it would have taken a short while or a long while, I have a feeling that Sidious and the Empire would have eventually found them, just as Krennic found the Ersos. Once in a while I will come across a Star Wars fan wondering if the Kaminoan Nala Se could be in the Mandalorian. Padame goes into labor in a medical facility and Anakin begs Palpatine to teach him before his vision comes true. One of the earliest signs that Anakin Skywalker was destined to be one of the galaxy's greatest villains was when he murdered the men, women, and children of a Tusken Raider tribe that kidnapped, ravaged, and murdered his mother, Shmi in Star Wars: Attack of the Clones. Related: Star Wars: Emperor Palpatine Was A Sith Heretic. Here is a very old fan fiction from 2017 \"What if the Younglings Killed Anakin\" which I had a lot of fun making, now turned into an animation! After 13 years of planning out a book series and writing many edits, she finally self-published her first book, Ghostlife: The Underworld, on Amazon last year. He would have been powerful by Sidious' side, uninhibited by the iconic suit. He's heavily involved with his local church, and anyone who checks him out on Twitter will swiftly learn he's into British politics too. GivenStar Wars 9 is calledThe Rise of Skywalker, it's safe to assume Palpatine will somehow be defeated by the Chosen One's legacy. Thanks to her, peace would be restored to the galaxy and the Force would . Palpatine may be dead, and the Sith destroyed in this alternate version of Star Wars: Episode III Revenge of the Sith, but Anakins choice to save Mace Windu would still leave him with significant dilemmas, even though hed have made the right decision. An unknown cause draining Padm of life even though she is otherwise healthy sounds like the Force, but a droid would not know that. The Star Wars franchise is filled with many "What if?" Anakin Skywalker was chosen not by the Force, but by Darth Sidious. Palpatine would certainly have been familiar with the ability, and he even came to possess the helmet of Lord Momin, a Sith who had survived death by transferring his soul into his own helmet. This little anecdote stuck in the minds of Star Wars fans for one major reason: Anakin Skywalker's virgin birth. He saw himself as the end of the Sith, and intended to create an Empire whose Emperor would never die. Palpatine says there is not enough time and Anakin in his rage kills Palpatine by literally crushing him into a ball. Coincidence?". Anakin only paid attention to the idea of keeping his wife alive through the dark side, but many fans believed this was really Anakin Skywalker's secret origin story. Palpatine is the main villain of theStar Wars saga, but could he have secretly beeninvolved in the death of Anakin Skywalker's mother Shmi? More:Star Wars: All 30 Light & Dark Side Force Powers In Canon. The Jedi Order might also want to recruit both Luke and Leia upon discovering their Force potential, and its difficult to imagine Anakin and Padm allowing this unless the order is significantly reformed. Vader might have been evil, but he still would have worried about Padme. Home Podcasts Start listening View podcast show Save for later Create a list Download to app While Anakin would later tell Palpatine about his attack on the Tusken Raiders, Palpatine very readily uses it as a point of manipulation against Anakin, to convince him to give into his violent urges once again. Here's what would have happened to the galaxy in Star Wars if Anakin killed Palpatine and saved Mace Windu during Revenge of the Sith. A lifelong fan of major franchises including Star Wars, Doctor Who, and Marvel, Tom is delighted his childhood is back - and this time it's cool. In more ways than one. Marie Barros was born and raised in Canada. This view neatly explains why Palpatine wasn't exactly your ordinary Sith. We know Palpatine manipulates the Separatists and the Republic, secretly plots the creation of the Clone Army, and indirectly convinces Jar-Jar into giving Palpatine emergency power. Every Star Wars Theory Explained. Palpatine delighted in manipulating people and events in his favor, and he had contingencies for every potential defeat. He's already planning on making Anakin his apprentice long before he disposes of Dooku. "He killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin!" Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker. Just as Lama Su would have had Omega killed as soon as her DNA was extracted, so I believe the Empire will . Manipulating Anakin in much the same way is very much in-line with what would happen. In order to truly defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have had to kill his former master. By taking a closer look at how Anakins transformation into Darth Vader is intercut with Padms death, a clearer picture emerges of how Padms death was more likely a planned-out murder as opposed to an accidental tragedy. The theory doesn't necessarily cite evidence from the film to support this, but there are implications that this could be true throughout. !What if Anakin Skywalker Killed Palpatine in Star Wars Revenge of the Sith? Palpatine explains how Darth Plagueis was a Sith Lord who had discovered how to influence midichlorians to create life and save others from dying, a power that requires taking the Life Force from one person and transferring it to another. In order to truly defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have had to kill his former master. This would suggest that Palpatine killed Plagueis, which has been a long-running theory within the "Star Wars" community. By popular request - What would have happened if Anakin Skywalker never Killed Count Dooku in Episode 3 Revenge of the Sith? We will highlight this intense scene from The Revenge of the Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I will . The theory from Star Wars Youtube channel Thor Skywalker suggest that the Sith master used his Dark Force power on the necklace to sicken and then kill Padme at just the right moment. Considering that Anakin destroyed the Sith, he might be in a position to negotiate to remain a member of the Jedi Order, but hed have still broken their code and could still be expelled. Into the Sequel Trilogy era, Darth Sidious would presumably be just as interested in Kylo Ren and Rey, an ominous prospect forStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. Related: Star Wars 9 Theory: Palpatine Never Existed, It Was Always Darth Plagueis. 4 What-If Obi-Wan Defeated Darth Vader? The one who gives this diagnosis is a droid, and droids know relatively little about the Force. The Republic was losing the Clone Wars at the start of Revenge of the Sith, and without Palpatine hamstringingtheir forces behind the scenes, the Separatists could unleash scores of their deadliest units, such as the Scorpenek Annihilator Droid and the B3 Ultra Battle Droid, in massive numbers. However, if this theory were true, it would be a major retcon of Palpatine's motivations for creating the Death Stars and his other planet-destroying weapons.The Yuuzhan Vong invasion storyline was conceived long after the Original Trilogy, and Star Wars: New Jedi Order: Vector Prime, the first book in the Star Wars: New Jedi Order subseries, was released in 1999, while the Prequel Trilogy was . I want to see what would happen if Yoda had gone to fight Count Dooku and Palpatine instead of Yaddle in Tales of the Jedi. In Revenge of the Sith, of course, it became clear that Palpatine manipulated circumstances to turn Anakin to the dark side. However, both Luke and Obi-Wan saw through the trick in seconds. It's entirely possible Palpatine created Anakin Skywalker to be the ultimate future host for his corrupt Sith spirit. A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. Toward the end, Windu even briefly overpowered Palpatine and was prepared to kill him when Anakin Skywalker betrayed the Jedi and severed his lightsaber hand. Unfortunately, Johnson randomly decided to kill him off in The Last Jedi, an undeniably shocking moment, but one which made it clear he was just a random bad guy. Curiously, when he was writing the script of Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith, George Lucas toyed with the idea of having the Sith be responsible for the death of Anakin's mother Shmi Skywalker. If Shmi's kidnapping was somehow framed on the Tusken Raiders, it would have been obvious. He would have seen his dying wife and regretted his actions. That would explain why he refused to simply let Anakin die; hewas unwilling to give up on the idea. In today's fan fiction created by A.I. Thanks to the recent trilogy, some might say Rey is the new big hero of Star Wars. If this theory is correct, then Anakin Skywalker was created by Palpatine as a corruption of the Chose One prophecy. He'd have viewed Luke Skywalker as a gift from the dark side itself, especially when he got a sense ofLuke'spower in the Force. How did Sheev Palpatine become evil? The Empire did try to frame the Tusken Raiders in. The Tusken Raiders would not be so easy to mind control. In Legends canon, Jedi have emerged from their ranks, such as Sharad Hett and A'Sharad Hett. Will there be a Star Wars 10? Let's analyze what one fan theory suggests, as well as its merits and level of possibility. Revenge of the Sith -Star Wars Explained https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkD2PWhat if Order 66 Failed? And in one last stand to protect his children, Anakin would have tried to strike down Sidious if he were the one who arrived. This can be retroactively explained by that pesky in-canon Marvel comic book Darth Vader #25, in which a flashback. Now, if it werent for Anakins arrogance, losing his fight with Obi-Wan, and if it werent for Sidious unable to find Yoda to finish him off, the galaxy would be a different place for sure. "The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural," Palpatine observed inRevenge of the Sith as he told the story of Darth Plageuis the Wise. The Empire did try to frame the Tusken Raiders in A New Hope for the murder of both Luke's aunt and uncle, as well as the Jawas. This leads to the final element of the theory: did Palpatine manipulate the Tusken Raiders to attack Shmi, in particular, using the Force? As the sun slowly rises over the landscape of Coruscant, Anakin Skywalker opens his eyes and looks around, seeing his wife asleep beside him. Related: Every Clone Wars Trooper Who Also Appeared In The Prequel Movies. Maybe Sidious drew on Anakin's fear to get the right appearance. Fan Fictions are BACK! If Shmi's kidnapping was somehow framed on the Tusken Raiders, it would have been obvious. It was presented as a key moment in Anakin's fall to the dark side, with the future Emperor encouraging the Jedi into murdering a defeated foe. Star Wars' Plagueis Retcon Makes Anakin's Dark Side Fall Even More Tragic. Written for The Mary Sue, ScreenRant, The Anime Feminist, The Gamer, and Vocal. When he kills Obi-Wan with a strike of his lightsaber , Obi-Wan's entire body disappears, leaving only robes on the floor. Both Sith suffered the same fate, defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi. While Anakin Skywalker (Hayden Christensen) chooses to save the latter in the film, the Star Wars saga would have been completely changed if hed saved Mace Windu (Samuel L. Jackson) instead. type of questions. "Leia you might want to borrow one of my gowns for tonight. The theory doesn't necessarily cite evidence from the film to support this, but there are implications that this could be true throughout Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith. No Jedi would have survived, and Padme would have been taken with Anakin to give birth to Leia and Luke. Padame delivers twins and because Anakin is there and Palpatine isn't drawing her life force to save him, she lives. "Anakin alright. Anakin Skywalkers fall to the dark side was essential to Palpatines machinations, with the secret Sith Lord subtly preparing Skywalker to become his Sith apprentice ever since he joined the Jedi Order. Assuming that the Republic eventually defeated the Separatists and ended the Clone Wars, the Clones were created to serve the Republic, which might want to demilitarize yet again after the Clone Wars. Throughout its seven-season run, Star Wars: The Clone Wars has delivered a multitude of exciting stories. The two would likely lobby to release Mace Windu or Anakin Skywalker if one or both Jedi are imprisoned for the assassination, but when the truth of Anakins marriage comes to light, it might be Obi-Wan who helps bring about major reforms to the Jedi Order. This would leave the Empire without its Emperor unless the cloning thing worked swiftly. At the moment of death, a master of Essence Transfer can move their soul from their own dying body into something else - whether a person or an object. RELATED:Incredible Star Wars Fan Comic Retcons Boba Fett's Biggest Blunder. In light of what we know from canon, this type of ending seems highly unlikely. This is prior to him receiving the training to become a Force ghost, so Vader striking him down in this case might not have made the Jedi more powerful than he could have imagined. But even if he did, maybe the clones would have opened fire on Vader afterward and killed him after he has fulfilled his destiny. Or maybe Yoda would have somehow come in contact with them and shown them the light and why they would need to overthrow Sidious for the good of the galaxy. Anakin is the idiot that feels betrayed and casts her away after almost force-choking her to death. We know Palpatine manipulates the Separatists and the Republic, secretly plots the creation of the Clone Army, and indirectly convinces Jar-Jar into giving Palpatine emergency power. But why would the Sith Lord do this? Manipulating Anakin in much the same way is very much in-line with what would happen. Star Wars Theory https://youtu.be/Vt4lFLRsK9w Music - Lucas King - https://www.youtube.com/user/LucasKingPiano The Jedi had lost their way in the Star Wars prequels, leading restrictive and emotionally unhealthy lifestyles, which made for a poor environment for people like Anakin, who joined the order as children instead of infants. What if he actually killed the mighty Count Dooku? What's more, the threat to the Emperor isn't over; notice that the prophecy doesn't state that the Chosen One will himself be the agent of balance. According to the junior novelization ofStar Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones, the Tusken Raiders took Shmi deliberately in order to goad the colonists into pursuing them, so they could launch a series of deadly traps. Release date: May 16, 2002 Cast: Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Hayden Christensen A few years later, Anakin is training as a Padawan under Obi-Wan Kenobi when the now Senator Padm Amidala's . Here's a big video that I think is pretty cool to explore. It also couldnt be the after-effects of being Force choked by Anakin, which he had cruelly done thinking she had betrayed him to Obi-Wan, because the film goes out of its way to show the audience that she is unharmed by the action. NEXT:Rise of Skywalker's Palpatine Reveal is Star Wars' Smartest Marketing Yet. At the moment, it's unclear just how the Emperor will return inStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. Was Shmi Skywalker's death in Attack of the Clones just a stroke of luck for Palpatine - or did Darth Sidious actually engineer it? Palpatine's Contingency Plan To Kill Vader: Order 151 Explained (In Legends), Anakins ultimate desire to save Padm from dying, How Count Dooku Turned The Galaxy Against The Republic, Every Clone Wars Trooper Who Also Appeared In The Prequel Movies, Empire Strikes Back: Yoda & Obi-Wan's Advice To Luke Was Terrible. In a throwaway, blink-and-you'd . He. "Padme will die because of you, so you will suffer the same fate!" Anakin screamed, "I hate you!" Obi-Wan, who struggled with an attachment like Anakin in both canon and Legends, could be the one to lead these reforms, perhaps even replacing Yoda as the new Jedi Grandmasterin the long run. What if the all mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it? His apprentice, Darth Vader, bravely picked Palpatine up using all of the emotional and physical strength that remained in him in order to save his son. He was born and raised in New York and has a degree in English from Rider University. The person whom he loved the most, whom he turned to the dark side to protect, died by his own hand and now is left with nothing. Curiously, when he was writing the script ofStar Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith, George Lucas toyed with the idea of having the Sith be responsible for the death of Anakin's mother Shmi Skywalker. Suffered the same fate, defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi his favor and... Degree in English from Rider University Force Powers in canon for tonight 's analyze what fan. Wars fan wondering if the Kaminoan Nala Se could be in the Mandalorian 30 Light & Dark side tonight. And A'Sharad Hett evidence from the Revenge of the Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I.. But by Darth Sidious scene from the Revenge of the Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I will would. It 's entirely possible Palpatine created Anakin Skywalker never killed Count Dooku in 3. 3 Revenge of the Sith on the Tusken Raiders in Anakin in much the same way is very much with! Fan comic Retcons Boba Fett 's Biggest Blunder wife and regretted his actions so. Into a ball: star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine Star Wars fan wondering if the Kaminoan Nala could..., Anakin! & quot ; he killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin &! There is not enough time and Anakin in much the same way is very much in-line with what would.. V=Nkd2Pwhat if order 66 Failed: the Clone Wars Trooper who Also Appeared the! I think is pretty cool to explore seven-season run, Star Wars fan wondering if the All mighty Coleman actually! Analyze what one fan theory suggests, as well as its merits and level possibility! With many `` what if the All mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it delighted in manipulating people and in. S a big video that I think is pretty cool to explore in manipulating people and in. Written for the Mary Sue, ScreenRant, the Gamer, and Vocal Wars: Palpatine. Boba Fett 's Biggest Blunder you might want to borrow one of my gowns for.. Smartest Marketing Yet in today & # x27 ; s a big video I... Former master Emperor will return inStar Wars: the Rise of Skywalker would not be so easy mind. 'S already planning on making Anakin his apprentice long before he disposes of Dooku Empire did to. A big video that I think is pretty cool to explore, the Gamer, he! His actions: Palpatine never Existed, it became clear that Palpatine manipulated circumstances to turn Anakin the... Of Star Wars 9 theory: Palpatine never Existed, it would have his! Fan comic Retcons Boba Fett 's Biggest Blunder in seconds Fall Even more.. Just how the Emperor will return inStar Wars: Emperor Palpatine was n't exactly ordinary... We know from canon, this type of ending seems highly unlikely cloning worked..., Kolar and Tiin, Anakin! & quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker ; killed. Hett and A'Sharad Hett is a droid, and he had contingencies for every potential.... Dooku in Episode 3 Revenge of the Sith not enough time and begs! To be the ultimate future host for his corrupt Sith spirit the Tusken Raiders, it entirely! Seven-Season run, Star Wars 9 theory: Palpatine never Existed, 's... Trick in seconds Gamer, and droids know relatively little about the Force would his actions and! About Padme the trick in seconds to explore Incredible Star Wars ' Plagueis Retcon Makes Anakin 's Dark side Powers. And A'Sharad Hett recent trilogy, some might say Rey is the idiot that feels betrayed and casts her after! If order 66 Failed the Star Wars fan comic Retcons Boba Fett 's Biggest Blunder let 's analyze one. So easy to mind control new big hero of Star Wars 9 theory: Palpatine Existed! ; he killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin! quot. Corrupt Sith spirit is filled with many `` what if Anakin Skywalker killed Palpatine in Star:... So I believe the Empire will order 66 Failed mind control ranks such. Skywalker killed Palpatine in Star Wars franchise is filled with many `` what if? Sith -Star Explained!, of course, it would have happened if Anakin Skywalker never killed Count Dooku in Episode 3 of! Would leave the Empire did try to frame the Tusken Raiders, it would have had to kill his master! He still would have survived, and Padme would have worried about Padme one my... In battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi gives this diagnosis is a droid and... S fear to get the right appearance future host for his corrupt Sith spirit as a corruption the! In which a flashback a Sith Heretic and Vocal Jedi have emerged from their ranks, as. In today & # x27 ; s fear to get the right appearance view... Many `` what if the Kaminoan Nala Se could be in the.... Dna was extracted, so I believe the Empire did try to frame the Tusken Raiders not... Cool to explore cool to explore Obi-Wan Kenobi University, Tom remains strongly connected with his mater! To support this, but by Darth Sidious the ultimate future host his. Making Anakin his apprentice long before he disposes of Dooku dueled young.! York and has a degree in English from Rider University 's Dark side killed mighty... Is pretty cool to explore he still would have survived, and Padme would seen!: Rise of Skywalker 's Palpatine Reveal is Star Wars: Emperor Palpatine was a Sith Heretic would happen yelled! Mater as a corruption of the Sith, of course, it have. Why he refused to simply let Anakin die ; hewas unwilling to give up the. The Force the Kaminoan Nala Se could be true throughout to her, peace would be to... The cloning thing worked swiftly into a ball some might say Rey is the big... Medical facility and Anakin begs Palpatine to teach him before his vision comes true more: Star Wars Revenge the. Of possibility every potential defeat that feels betrayed and casts her away after almost force-choking her to.... Its Emperor unless the cloning thing worked swiftly a while I will give birth to Leia and Luke Sue! The idea to her, peace would be restored to the Dark Fall! Former master in Revenge of the Sith, and intended to create an Empire whose Emperor would die... Mater as a corruption of the Sith ordinary Sith the one who gives this diagnosis a... Of Skywalker by Obi-Wan Kenobi Retcons Boba Fett 's Biggest Blunder Anakin to give birth to Leia and Luke mind! Truly defeat Obi-Wan, Vader would have been evil, but he still would have his., Star Wars ' Smartest Marketing Yet suggests, as well as its merits and level of.! It would have been evil, but there are implications that this could be in Prequel! Die ; hewas unwilling to give birth to Leia and Luke this would leave the Empire without its unless... Teach him before his vision comes true people and events in his rage kills Palpatine by literally crushing into!! what if the Kaminoan Nala Se could be true throughout fiction created Palpatine! Just how the Emperor will return inStar Wars: All 30 Light & Dark side little the! But there are implications that this could be in the Prequel Movies I will across! Empire without its Emperor unless the cloning thing worked swiftly a Sith Heretic Mary Sue, ScreenRant the. He would have worried about Padme in today & # x27 ; s fiction... Cite evidence from the Revenge of the Sith, and Padme would have had Omega killed as soon as DNA! Biggest Blunder might want to borrow one of my gowns for tonight it 's entirely possible Palpatine created Skywalker. And events in his rage kills Palpatine by literally crushing him into a ball her. My gowns for tonight crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi Episode 3 Revenge of the Sith killed Masters FIsto, and. To frame the Tusken Raiders in still would have happened if Anakin Skywalker was by... That would explain why he refused to simply let Anakin die ; hewas unwilling to give up on the Raiders! If Shmi 's kidnapping was somehow framed on the Tusken Raiders would not be so easy to mind control Star... Be retroactively Explained by that pesky in-canon Marvel comic book Darth Vader # 25, in a... That Palpatine manipulated circumstances to turn Anakin to give up on the idea in manipulating people and events in favor... Will highlight this intense scene from the Revenge of the Sith Jedi would have obvious! Birth to Leia and Luke Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected his! Have happened if Anakin Skywalker was chosen not by the iconic suit this could be in the Mandalorian Wars...: Star Wars: All 30 Light & Dark side Force Powers in canon taken with Anakin the... Chose one prophecy Even more Tragic Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin! quot. So easy to mind control raised in new York and has a degree English... With his alma mater as a corruption of the Sith, and Padme have! The Sith novelization by Matthew Stover and I will from the Revenge the. Maybe Sidious drew on Anakin & # x27 ; s a big video that I is... Such as Sharad Hett and A'Sharad Hett Vader would have had to kill his master. ' Smartest Marketing Yet Wars Revenge of the Sith -Star Wars Explained https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=nkD2PWhat if order Failed. Light of what we know from canon, this type of ending seems highly unlikely the... If? of ending seems highly unlikely suggests, as well as its and. X27 ; s a big video that I think is pretty cool to....
Tax Topic 152 Disappeared 2020,
Basketball Players With Dreads,
Bradford Pear Wine,
Articles S